CO2 Fick principle, for example, NICO® | - Good agreement between NICO® and ultrasound transit time
- Patient may be breathing spontaneously or on a ventilator
| - Accuracy adversely affected by hyperventilation and V/Q mismatch (preexisting lung disease or postoperative atelectasis)
| Yes; however, patient must be intubated |
Esophageal Doppler, for example, CardioQ (single use), WAKIe TO (reusable) | - High validity for monitoring changes in cardiac output in critically ill patients
- Using esophageal Doppler to optimize fluid management has been shown to improve outcomes
| - Patient must be intubated and sedated
- Small risk of injury to the esophagus
- Limited agreement with thermodilution
| No, requires placement of probe in the esophagus |
Transpulmonary lithium dilution, for example, LiDCO | - High signal-to-noise ratio
- Good agreement with thermodilution
- Low risk of toxicity
| - Not approved for patients <40 kg, pregnant women, or patients taking lithium
- Accuracy reduced by aortic insufficiency, intra-aortic balloon pump, nondepolarizing NMB
| No, requires an intra-arterial line |
Arterial pulse contour analysis, for example, Vigileo® | - Good agreement with other methods of cardiac output determination
- Continuous measurement of SV and CO
- Also display SVV (SV variation) with a value >15% indicating fluid responsiveness
- Easy to use
| - Adversely affected by a poor arterial waveform (arrhythmia, intra-aortic balloon pump)
- Older devices may not adequately compensate for changes in vascular tone
- Newer devices have good agreement with thermodilution and esophageal Doppler
| No, requires an intra-arterial line |
Bioimpedance, for example, Cheetah NICOM®, BioZ Dx® | - Completely noninvasive
- Impedance to high-frequency current between electrodes on chest; estimates thoracic blood volume
| - Relative hemodynamic stability required
- Accuracy reduced by arrhythmias, aortic insufficiency, intra-aortic balloon pump
- Contraindicated in patients with pacemakers
| Yes, adhesive surface electrodes only |